As
long as I don't get to put African-American or Asian on my legal paperwork because
I was not born African-American or Asian, and I can't wear "blackface" on
Halloween, then a man cannot steal my gender identity just
because he feels like a woman. I just read that people are up in arms about Scarlett Johansson playing a role in the US-based live action Ghost in the Shell movie, because she's white. And yet, for all the vitriol thrown at her, I'm not allowed to say no to penises coming into my changing room?
I am biologically a woman and I am clearly more disenfranchised than any "racial" group, because in some places penises are being permitted in my facilities when they haven't the plumbing, even though they haven't experienced the suffering, visited upon my kind by biological facts I am not allowed any choice in - same as everyone else.
I love this article, called When Did Using a Bathroom Get So Complicated? by Dr. Meg Meeker. I heartily agree with her findings and opinion. As long as a penis has a penis, it belongs in the penis or unisex facilities. Likewise, as long as a vagina has a vagina, it belongs in the vagina or unisex facilities.
I am biologically a woman and I am clearly more disenfranchised than any "racial" group, because in some places penises are being permitted in my facilities when they haven't the plumbing, even though they haven't experienced the suffering, visited upon my kind by biological facts I am not allowed any choice in - same as everyone else.
I love this article, called When Did Using a Bathroom Get So Complicated? by Dr. Meg Meeker. I heartily agree with her findings and opinion. As long as a penis has a penis, it belongs in the penis or unisex facilities. Likewise, as long as a vagina has a vagina, it belongs in the vagina or unisex facilities.
Did you just have gender reassignment surgery? Super. Now that you don't have your swanky old penis, I'm fine with letting you in a place where girls and women have a right to privacy, because now you can't force penile rape them upon or give them an eyeful of what they'd rather not see. I have no desire to risk the safety of the many for the sensibilities of the few, as has already happened in chilling reports from the US and Canada alike. I don't think it makes any transgender less of a transgender to use the bathroom specified for whatever plumbing he or she has.
ZERO
POINT THREE PERCENT of Americans claim to identify as transgender. That
isn't to say the feelings of individuals considering themselves
transgender aren't important, but I am not
more interested in tending to the sensitivities of 0.3% of
the population when fully 50.8% of the population are females endangered
by allowing penises claiming to identify as females into female
facilities. As the articles above have proven, that's where these policies tend
to lead - the continued victimization of girls and women.
Is it transgendered persons' fault that deviants and criminals will utilize such policies to prey on girls and women? No. However, for the same rationale that TSA has power to search the body and belongings of US citizens to keep the rest of the population safe from potential attack, I think that any individual with male parts attached can be kept out of female facilities.
Is it transgendered persons' fault that deviants and criminals will utilize such policies to prey on girls and women? No. However, for the same rationale that TSA has power to search the body and belongings of US citizens to keep the rest of the population safe from potential attack, I think that any individual with male parts attached can be kept out of female facilities.
Now, getting personal: I want to say a giant screw you to any penis who thinks he has the right to call himself a woman when he has never had to suffer the blood rites or blatant misogyny visited upon femalekind by medical professionals, bosses, coworkers, and laymen alike. That is my personal stance from my lifetime of experiences as a genuine vag, and I also think it's disrespectful of the male gender for a female to live as one when she hasn't suffered the misandry and biological difficulties visited upon malekind. By and large, biology is a fact, not a choice, and many of us suffer because of it.
Even with gender reassignment, on a personal level I still will never consider a penis who's had his penis removed to have earned my gender. You will never be a woman in my book. ALSO: You're not intersex, and how dare those of you you even try to identify with the 1.7% of individuals who have truly struggled to find themselves when you were given something concrete at birth, something they had to struggle with in a way you never will. You're not them. You are nothing like them. Your struggles are not real and nowhere near as valid as theirs, and how dare you think to compare yourself to them. It's not the same. A physical deformity is not a choice.

